Caveat Emptor In Real Estate: What You Should Know

Buying a home can be confusing enough without introducing Latin phrases. The term "caveat emptor" means "buyer beware." It’s a warning that when you buy things, it's at your own risk due to information asymmetry, where the seller knows more. The phrase relates to product liability and can apply to real property and garage sales where there may be defective products.

Contract law sometimes uses this term, and it's like saying you're responsible for your choice because sellers might know more. So, if you end up with something broken, it's your problem, not theirs. Read on to learn how the concept applies to real estate transactions and how to protect yourself as either a buyer or seller.

Caveat Emptor In Real Estate

In real estate, the principle of caveat emptor means that buyers are responsible for thoroughly investigating a property before making a purchase. Although the seller is responsible for being truthful about the state of the property, they are off the hook regarding issues that the buyer identifies after the closing. Also, a real estate agent can assist buyers, but due diligence to avoid being a victim of misrepresentation rests with the buyer.

While caveat emptor was the standard in the U.S. for many years, some states are bucking the trend in favor of buyers. Since the seller knows the condition of the property better than the buyer, courts have started to side with buyers.

For instance, if the seller wrongly installed an air-conditioning system, then sold you the property, the seller could be on the hook for it. If you were to hire a contractor who could prove the system was improperly installed, you might be able to convince the court to rule in your favor.

What Are Sellers Required To Disclose?

Most states have laws requiring home sellers to provide a Seller’s Disclosure statement. Even in real estate transactions where the principle of caveat emptor applies, sellers are often legally obligated to disclose certain information to buyers and not intentionally mislead them.

Commonly required disclosures include:

• Material defects or issues with the property that could affect its value or safety, which might include structural problems, leaks, or pest infestations
• Environmental hazards, such as toxic substances or radon gas
• Legal disputes, including any ongoing or past disputes related to the property, like boundary disputes, zoning violations, or pending lawsuits
• Recent repairs, renovations, and permits obtained for them, so buyers understand the condition and history of the property
• Some jurisdictions require death or crime disclosures if a death occurred on the property or if it was the scene of a crime
• Neighborhood information, such as noise levels, traffic, or planned developments that could impact the property's value
• If the property is part of a homeowners association (HOA), the seller should provide information on rules, fees, and pending assessments
• For properties built before 1978, sellers must provide information about the presence of lead-based paint and hazards associated with it
• If the property is in a designated flood zone, sellers typically need to disclose this

Examples Of Caveat Emptor

The principle of caveat emptor with real estate transactions may apply to hidden structural damage you discover after closing. Likewise, with unseen pest problems, such as termites, you may have to deal with the issue on your own.

Caveat emptor can also apply to the purchase of used personal property. You may need to handle the repairs if you buy a car and later identify engine issues. The same applies to problems you may discover with garage sale goods.

Be Extra Cautious Of Caveat Emptor In These States

There’s an overall trend in residential real estate moving toward protecting the buyer. Thus, many jurisdictions no longer enforce caveat emptor in all cases. Although all states allow caveat emptor sales, there is a short list of states that lean in this direction, including:

• Alabama
• Arkansas
• Georgia
• North Dakota
• Virginia
• Wyoming

Caveat emptor may not hold up in court outside these states. However, each state has different laws, so research and talk with your real estate agent or lawyer about the risk you could be taking before buying real estate.

How To Reduce Your Risk As A Buyer

Buyers must advocate for themselves, especially in areas where caveat emptor is more common. Before closing, inspect the property, and hire professionals to assess its condition. Conduct a title search to ensure there are no ownership disputes, liens, or other claims, and get the property appraised to ensure it is fairly priced.

Read the Closing Disclosure carefully, which is a legal document the seller provides that lists known damage, defects, repairs, and concerns with the home. Also, learn about consumer protection laws in your area and what the seller is required and not required to disclose. Also, beware of disclaimer clauses in the real estate contract because an as is contract typically favors the seller by reducing or eliminating product liability.

Ask the seller or their agent lots of questions and record the answers. For example, inquire about the condition of the roof, if the basement has ever flooded, or if there are problems with mold.

Consider purchasing a home warranty, which can cover repairs and replacements for major systems and appliances. Warranties can provide an added layer of protection against unexpected expenses.

Caveat Venditor: The New Standard?

The opposite of caveat emptor is caveat venditor, or “let the seller beware.” In some cases, caveat venditor has become more prevalent than caveat emptor. The trend in court in some states favors buyer protection, so the seller may need to take extra steps to protect themselves. This principle encourages transparency, honesty and accountability in business transactions and can apply to real estate and consumer products.

Caveat venditor aligns with the concept of implied warranties, which is an unwritten assurance that a product will meet certain quality and performance standards. Sellers are responsible for ensuring that the products they sell are fit for their intended purpose and are of satisfactory quality. If a buyer communicates a particular purpose for a product, the seller should provide guidance and ensure that the product is suitable for that purpose.

Protecting yourself as the seller starts with disclosing everything you’ve done with the property or any property concerns. This includes repairs, property defects or potential property disputes.

Caveat Emptor FAQs

Review the following frequently asked questions to learn more about caveat emptor.

How is caveat emptor used?

Caveat emptor emphasizes that buyers are responsible for conducting their own due diligence and being cautious when making real estate purchases. Therefore, due diligence to uncover problems before closing is essential, as sellers might not disclose problems willingly. If a buyer discovers issues after the purchase, they might not be able to hold the seller accountable, except in cases of intentional misrepresentation. 

Is caveat emptor considered ethical?

The ethical status of "caveat emptor" is a subject of debate. While it acknowledges the importance of due diligence for the buyers, it can also lead to potential power imbalances between buyers and sellers and unfair outcomes. As a result, many modern legal systems and ethical frameworks advocate for a balanced approach that combines buyer responsibility with seller transparency and accountability.

The Bottom Line: Protect Yourself From ‘Buyer Beware’ Transactions

To safeguard yourself in "buyer beware" situations, thoroughly research a property’s condition and potential issues before purchasing. Read the closing disclosure carefully, be wary of disclosure clauses, and consider getting a home warranty. By being informed, vigilant, and thorough, you can protect yourself from potential risks and make more confident purchasing decisions.

Ready to become a homeowner? Apply for mortgage approval today.